Do you ever have that feeling where everything was going so well, and then out of nowhere, seemingly, it wasn't. Of course, putting it like that it feels obvious that it happens to everyone in all sorts of situations. Or maybe that's just me :).
Anyhow, finally finished my many month journey through Asimov's Foundation universe, spanning the Robot, Galactic Empire and Foundation series. For the most part it was fantastic! It had been over fifteen years since my last read through, and there was so much I enjoyed. And of course a lot that I discovered this time around that felt new.
But then there was the end of Foundation and Earth.
The thing is, I don't didn't remember at all what I thought of it last time around. So I went and looked it up. Turns out in one way it was a familiar feeling, I didn't recall any of the end from the read prior. Doesn't seem like I was left with the same sort of feeling of being let down though.
Is it another one of those things where you feel differently about similar things at different times because you're a different person in some ways? Lived experiences do change us don't they? I mean, that's one of the benefits of life I think, the opportunity to evolve.
So what is it that's left me somewhat, shall we say, disgruntled? Without going into specifics, I think the first thing to consider is how the ending of Foundation and Earth seems to clearly set up some sort of new direction. A new source of crises to the galaxy from beyond the boundaries hitherto explored.
I have always wondered a bit why Asimov decided, having given humanity the ability to blithely bypass the challenges of faster than light travel, to confine them to a single galaxy. But for the most part that's been part of the story, galactic empire and all that. It's only at the very end that he looks beyond, and that feels quite jarring. Particularly as he looks beyond with a distinct sense of belligerence and disquiet.
I think that's the problem I'm having. For the majority of the books, accounting for the time when particular stories were written, there is a sense of looking forward with positivity. A sense that despite everything, a positive outcome is worth fighting for, because it is possible to bring about.
Through most of the last book though, there's a sense of foreboding. The decision has been made, now we are engaging in some monumental amount of navel gazing to justify our actions. And what a crap justification we are left with in the end!
OK, it's not actually possible to leave this entirely spoiler free, so be warned. I think another thing (or maybe this is the main thing) that really annoyed me was having come so neatly full circle with Daneel's lunar hideaway, why is he turned into such a cardboard cutout of a character?!
It feels genuinely bizarre to me that Asimov in fact wrote what I consider the absolutely most enjoyable books of the entire lot - The Robots of Dawn, Robots and Empire, Prelude to Foundation and Forward the Foundation - pretty much around Foundation and Earth, just before, or just after. How could those others have turned out so differently?
Maybe the mistake really is mine. Maybe the best way to read these books are really in the order they were published. Although, given that I did read it in in-universe (or should I say in-galaxy) chronological order, I did get to read all my favourite ones all together. So there is that :).

































